Teaching Students to Reverse Engineer Business Decisions (The CSI Method for Data)

AI prompts that generate business decision mysteries for students to solve backwards, building detective skills that transform data analysts into strategic thinkers.

You know those CSI crime shows where investigators arrive at a scene and work backwards to figure out exactly what happened?

Your students need that same investigative mindset for business decisions.

Here's what happens in every data classroom:

Students run brilliant analysis and hand back findings like "Sales increased 23% in December" or "Customer satisfaction averaged 4.2 stars."

Then you ask, "What should the company do about this?" Silence.

They can find patterns but can't connect them to real business choices.

The gap: Students learn technical skills but never learn to think like the executives who actually use their analysis to make decisions.

The solution: Give students a business decision that already happened, then have them work backwards to identify what evidence would have been most important for that choice.

---

Test This Right Now

Give your students this mystery:

"Netflix canceled a show after one season despite 15 million viewers in the first month."

Ask: "What evidence would have been most critical for this decision?"

Typical answers:
"Viewership, ratings, social media buzz, production costs."

Strategic answers:
"Completion rates, cost per new subscriber, production cost increases for season 2, budget opportunity cost."

You'll immediately see who understands that business decisions involve trade-offs and resource allocation, not just performance tracking.

---

Why AI Changes This Teaching Method

Before AI:
You'd borrow scenarios from textbooks (felt academic), colleagues (didn't fit your class), or last year's materials (students found on Reddit). Every case needed hours of adaptation.

With AI:
Generate fresh, tailored mysteries in 30 seconds. Every scenario feels current and exactly right for your students.

What this enables:
You can create new mysteries every class instead of recycling cases. Students can't look up answers. No more explaining why you're using outdated examples.

---

The Business Mystery Generator